Social Science History 2004 28(1):19-52; DOI:10.1215/01455532-28-1-19
Duke University Press
Hedging His Bets
Why Nixon Killed HUD's Desegregation Efforts
Chris Bonastia
Abstract
Drawing on primary sources from the Nixon Presidential Materials and the
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), this article examines HUD's
attempts during the Nixon era to implement "pro-integrative"
policies and the White House response to these efforts. Specifically, this
article provides an explanation for why President Richard Nixon elected to
dismantle residential integration initiatives while allowing similar policies
in employment and education to proceed with some force. In contrast to
existing work arguing that Nixon's civil rights positions were designed to
maximize political payoffs, I contend that Nixon's strategies are more
accurately characterized as blame avoidance. Whenever possible, Nixon
attempted to shift the onus of political responsibility for controversial
civil rights decisions onto other political actors. This argument is clarified
by a second primary theoretical point, which argues that institutional
vulnerability increases the likelihood of presidential attacks. In the case
examined here, HUD's distinctive institutional weaknessshaped by its
conflicting missions and unwieldy structure, and laid bare by scandals in the
Federal Housing Administrationgave the president a relatively low-risk
political opportunity to dismantle civil rights efforts, a chance he did not
have in the areas of education and employment.

CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us
Digg
Reddit
Technorati What's this?
Copyright 2004 by Social Science History Association