Social Science History 2004 28(1):75-109; DOI:10.1215/01455532-28-1-75
Duke University Press
The Rhetoric of Black Abolitionism
An Exploratory Analysis of Antislavery Newspapers in New York State
Timothy Shortell
Abstract
In a span of thirty years, from 1832 to 1862, American abolitionists
were able to reverse public opinion in the North on the question of slavery.
Despite the dramatic political shift, the emergent hostility to "slave
power" did not lead to an embrace of racial equality. Abolitionists, in
the face of America's long history of racism, sought to link opposition to
slavery with a call for civil rights. For black abolitionists, this was not
only a strategic problem, it was a matter of self-definition. In the middle of
the nineteenth century, the meanings of liberty, labor, and independence were
the basis of contentious republican politics. Black abolitionists used this
rhetorical raw material to fashion "fighting words" with which to
generate solidarity and deliver their moral claims to the nation. This
research employs an innovative strategy for the analysis of the discursive
field, in an exploratory content analysis of five black newspapers in
antebellum New York State. Computerized content analysis coded for themes,
rhetoric, and ideology in a sample of more than 36,000 words of newspaper
text. Although the discourse of black abolitionism is a social critique, it
also contains a positive assertion of what free blacks would become. As
important as the theme of "slavery" was to the discourse, so too
were "colored" and "brotherhood." This analysis
consistently showed the key features of political antislavery argumentation to
be most common in the Douglass newspapers (the North Star
and Frederick Douglass' Paper).

CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us
Digg
Reddit
Technorati What's this?
Copyright 2004 by Social Science History Association